Background of Illegal Immigration in the U.S.
The story of illegal immigration as a prominent political concern in the United States begins in the mid-20th century, though its origins are deeply tied to earlier economic trends and legislative shifts. The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965 was a key turning point; abolishing restrictive quotas that had previously limited migration from Latin America and Asia opened new avenues for lawful immigration. Yet, as demand grew for labor in industries such as agriculture and manufacturing, undocumented immigration began to rise, as the newly reformed legal framework did not adequately address the economic needs of the U.S. labor market¹.
By the 1980s, public attention turned sharply to undocumented immigration due to rising concerns over job competition and wage pressures, especially for lower-income workers. President Ronald Reagan’s 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) sought to curb illegal immigration through employer sanctions and a one-time amnesty provision for millions already residing in the U.S. without legal status². This reform, however, struggled to reduce future illegal migration and led to further divisions as public opinion began to see illegal immigration not just as an economic issue but as a matter of national security.
The tragic events of 9/11 brought new scrutiny to immigration policy, as border security and illegal immigration became more closely associated with national security risks. As the 21st century progressed, partisan differences solidified; while some advocated for tighter border controls and stronger enforcement, others emphasized reform that would allow for pathways to citizenship for individuals who had established their lives in the U.S. This divergence in perspectives has set the tone for the polarized immigration debate that continues today, with illegal immigration frequently emerging as a central issue in U.S. politics³.
Current State of Illegal Immigration
Today, illegal immigration remains a focal point in policy discussions, reflecting concerns over economic, social, and security implications. The Department of Homeland Security estimates the U.S. population of undocumented immigrants to be around 11 million, a figure that has seen only moderate fluctuations over the past decade⁴. A significant portion of recent immigration activity, particularly along the southern border, involves families and unaccompanied minors seeking asylum, which adds complexity to traditional immigration policies. Border states, including Texas and Arizona, face considerable logistical challenges in managing the flow of migrants, with some federal resources directed to alleviating pressures on local facilities⁵.
Programs such as Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), introduced under the Obama administration in 2012, further underscore the legal and social challenges facing undocumented immigrants. While DACA provides temporary protection from deportation and work authorization for young people who arrived as minors, its ongoing legal challenges illustrate the limited durability of executive action in the face of fluctuating public opinion⁶. At the state level, policies vary widely; some have adopted sanctuary city laws that prioritize community safety over immigration enforcement, while others, such as Alabama and Arizona, have introduced restrictive laws aiming to limit undocumented immigrants' access to public services⁷.
Impacts on Society and the Economy
The effects of illegal immigration on the economy and society are complex and multifaceted. Economically, undocumented immigrants provide essential labor in agriculture, hospitality, and construction sectors, where labor shortages are acute, contributing both through direct employment and as consumers⁸. Studies show that undocumented immigrants pay billions in taxes annually but are often ineligible for the social services that these taxes fund, such as Social Security and Medicare⁹. Opponents argue that this group may depress wages in certain low-skilled sectors, creating economic pressure on local workers, especially in communities where public resources are strained¹⁰.
Socially, immigration has enriched U.S. communities with diverse cultures and traditions, though tensions can arise over assimilation, language, and access to services. Localities with high immigration rates, particularly along the southern border, often serve as microcosms of the national debate, balancing the benefits of diversity with concerns over resources, schooling, and healthcare costs. A Pew Research study shows that while some areas have adopted inclusive policies, other communities face heightened polarization and anti-immigrant sentiment, underscoring the social divisiveness of the issue¹¹. Despite these challenges, many immigrant communities have demonstrated strong social cohesion, contributing to neighborhood revitalization and local economic growth¹².
Addressing the Issue and Future Policy Approaches
Developing effective policies to address illegal immigration involves reconciling economic needs, humanitarian concerns, and security interests. One prominent proposal in recent years includes implementing a more comprehensive E-Verify system, which would require employers to confirm the work authorization of new hires electronically, thus reducing illegal employment opportunities. Strengthening the visa system to create legal channels for seasonal and skilled labor is another widely discussed option, which could relieve pressure on the undocumented labor market by addressing the underlying demand for foreign labor¹³.
Legislation at the state level has further diversified the national approach to immigration policy. California, for example, has adopted measures to integrate undocumented immigrants by granting driver’s licenses and in-state college tuition to undocumented students. Arizona, in contrast, has implemented stringent measures such as SB 1070, which allows law enforcement to check immigration status during routine stops, stirring national debate over civil liberties¹⁴. While Congress has attempted various bipartisan immigration reforms, partisan divisions have often led to gridlock, making state-level approaches critical yet inconsistent.
Conclusion
Illegal immigration remains a deeply entrenched and multifaceted issue in American society, as much a matter of economic pragmatism as it is of national identity. Legislative and executive efforts to address illegal immigration have achieved limited success, given the diverging public and political perspectives on reform, enforcement, and inclusion. With the national debate showing few signs of subsiding, future immigration policy will need to balance practical solutions that acknowledge the economic contributions of undocumented immigrants while addressing the social and security concerns of affected communities. Achieving such balance will be essential for the U.S. to maintain both the integrity of its borders and the vitality of its diverse social fabric.
---
Resources
¹ Ngai, Mae M. “The Rise of Illegal Immigration in the United States.” Harvard University Press, 2004.
² "Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) of 1986." U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, 2021.
³ Alden, Edward. “The Closing of the American Border: Terrorism, Immigration, and Security Since 9/11.” HarperCollins, 2008.
⁴ "Estimates of the Undocumented Population in the United States." Department of Homeland Security, 2022.
⁵ "Annual Border Apprehensions Report." U.S. Customs and Border Protection, 2021.
⁶ "Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA): Current Status." American Immigration Council, 2021.
⁷ "Sanctuary Policies and State-Level Immigration Laws." National Conference of State Legislatures, 2021.
⁸ Hanson, Gordon H., “Economic and Fiscal Consequences of Immigration.” National Academy of Sciences, 2016.
⁹ “Tax Contributions by Immigrant Communities.” Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, 2020.
¹⁰ Borjas, George J., “The Labor Market Impact of Immigration.” Journal of Economic Literature, 2016.
¹¹ "Social Impacts of Immigration." Pew Research Center, 2021.
¹² "The Economic and Social Integration of Immigrant Communities." Urban Institute, 2020.
¹³ "Employment Verification and Labor Needs." Migration Policy Institute, 2022.
¹⁴ "Arizona SB 1070 and State-Level Immigration Policy." American Civil Liberties Union, 2021.